Public Architects Committee

 View Only
Expand all | Collapse all

WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

  • 1.  WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-03-2023 02:55 PM

    The Public Architects knowledge community has more than 4,900+ members and I've been wondering about who you are, why you follow this discussion forum, and what are your major challenges today.  So here is my quick answer - I would love to hear yours!

    WHO:  I am a public architect in service to a public university (MA) campus of 13.8M GSF.  I've done every kind of work at multiple scales - studies, designs, renovations, new buildings, LEED strategy, master plans, etc..  

    WHAT: AIR & EGRESS.  I am working on reconfiguring 8,000 sf of the floor in a historic brutalist library building and trying to compartmentalize an open office space with tight constrains between the vertical core/air, the periphery/air and allow for privacy, egress and accessible restrooms.  And then the SWING SPACE to allow the work to happen.

    I'd love to hear from you.  What are you working on?



    ------------------------------
    Ludmilla Pavlova-Gillham AIA
    University of Massachusetts
    Amherst MA
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-06-2023 10:31 AM

    WHO:  Career federal architect, last 20+ years at Headquarters, US Army Corps of Engineers.  Currently responsible for portfolio of $300 million of master planning, facilities standards, and military construction validation.

    WHY: To keep in touch with trends and concerns within public sector practice.

    WHAT: DATA GOVERNANCE and COLLABORATION.  I am working with our R&D labs to create a digital platform for installation master planning, merging multiple facility databases and GIS that will become a single window to make real-time, data driven decisions on installation resilience, climate change, energy and water efficiency, and stationing of troop units between installations.  On collaboration, getting our 12 planning support centers to work in collaboration versus competition. Our clients are national and international in scope, requiring collaboration among all to assure consistency in the quality of projects and products.



    ------------------------------
    Edmond Gauvreau, FAIA
    Washington, DC
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-07-2023 05:47 PM

    Ed, I am really glad you brought up the issue of data governance and collaboration - knowledge management is such a challenge when it comes to developing data/content and maintaining it in a meaningful way so that it can spur collaboration.  GIS tools can definitely help!  I would love to see some graphic examples of what you are doing and how metrics facilitate making decisions.  Thank you for your reply.



    ------------------------------
    Ludmilla Pavlova-Gillham AIA
    University of Massachusetts
    Amherst MA
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-08-2023 05:53 PM

    WHO: I am the TN State Architect and provide real estate and capital projects expertise for the State Building Commission in their work overseeing the states 110M sq ft and 900K acre portfolio. My office prepares documents and agenda items for commission approval, reviews and recommends all procurement documents for related to real estate or project transactions, reviews and signs all designer and contractor agreements, approves gift projects, serves as the primary client or resource for all work for the capitol complex or TN residence, reviews and recommends all new construction design for approval, approves all capital grant invoicing, and various other items. I work directly and equally for the commission members which consist of the Governor, Lt. Gov and Speaker of the Senate, Speaker of the House, Secretary of State, Comptroller of the Treasury, State Treasurer and Commissioner of Finance and Administration.

     

    WHAT: Making sure that the approximately $9.5Billion in work that has been approved by the legislature since 2020 is completed in a timely manner, achieves the intended purpose, and reflects good stewardship of the taxpayer funds.

     

    Ann McGauran | TN State Architect 

    Department of Treasury

    Andrew Jackson Building, 15th Floor

    502 Deaderick Street, Nashville, TN 37243

    c. 615-934-7311

    https://www.tn.gov/osa

     






  • 5.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-07-2023 11:39 AM

    WHO:  I don't hold a "public architect" position per se but I am the Assistant Planning Director for Oklahoma City, the 20th largest city by population and the second largest by land area.

    WHAT:  It seems we are never able to react fast enough to address climate and other environmental concerns, housing, homelessness services, and new technologies like providing EV parking spaces. There are always so many stakeholders to inform and persuade when we tackle any initiative.



    ------------------------------
    Lisa Chronister FAIA
    City of Oklahoma City
    Oklahoma City OK
    ------------------------------



  • 6.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-07-2023 05:19 PM

    Thanks for your reply, Lisa!  My sense is that if you are an architect and you serve a public entity such as Oklahoma City (!) - then you are, indeed, a public architect.  I have similar challenges - how to serve many stakeholders (by informing, persuading, empowering, leading, etc.)  Your experience as an architect and a Fellow must be exceedingly valuable to the Oklahoma administration. 



    ------------------------------
    Ludmilla Pavlova-Gillham AIA
    University of Massachusetts
    Amherst MA
    ------------------------------



  • 7.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-09-2023 07:32 AM

    I work as an architect for the US Courts.  We do a lot, but I guess the security items are what keep you at the most.






  • 8.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-11-2023 02:32 PM
    I am so thrilled to have discovered this group at A'23 in SF this past June. From reading everyone's stories here, it is inspiring to hear all of the "too big to digest" problems and projects you are humbly tackling...

    WHO: I am a Program Executive in the Front End Planning unit for Public Buildings at the NYC Department of Design and Construction (DDC). I also am working with our Deputy Director of Advanced Capital Planning at DDC to build a new database portal to improve our capital planning process for use by our agency and our partnering agencies. Edmond, I would love to connect to discuss what you have been finding in the development of your portal. 

    Outside of DDC, I am the leading advisor of AIANY's Civic Leadership Program with the mission to develop a class of emerging architectural professionals into civic leaders by refining the skills that design professionals need to better represent the people that they serve. We do this by increasing architects' connections to their communities, developing their advocacy capacities, and supporting their pursuit of public service in elected or appointed office. 

    WHAT: As the City's leading construction management agency, DDC builds infrastructure and public buildings for more than 20 sponsoring City agencies, plus numerous non-profits that receive funding from the City. My role in Front End Planning is to review and analyze our sponsor (client) agency project requests to determine if potential projects are suitable for initiation.  This includes the analysis of programmatic needs, site planning, building codes and local laws, zoning, architectural design and historic preservation, engineering systems, sustainability, project scheduling, and cost estimating. 

    What keeps me up at night is the strange feeling that the building of the Advanced Capital Planning Portal is one of the most creative projects I've worked on in both the private and public sectors. For the first time, I am helping to build something that is not a building, and learning how to implement design and usability in a different kind of construction. 

    Looking forward to continuing the conversation with you all. 





  • 9.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-11-2023 06:02 PM

    Jenna, we are thrilled you are thrilled.  It is always wonderful to collaborate and discuss with our colleagues who work in the public sector.  I am particularly loving the term "Sponsoring Agency" that you use and Margaret Castillo also used when I was in a conversation with her some time ago.  This is another discussion topic I would like to address.  

    Ever since I heard the term from Margaret, I have started a grass roots effort in SF to start using the term instead of "Clients".  I also see you used the term "partner agencies".  In the last couple of years we have been getting a lot of the "I am the Client" kind of notes from our sponsoring agencies and I will take some responsibility towards this because when I started I also took on the attitude that we serve our clients which is true, but in some ways the pendulum has swung far the other way.  As our true clients are the public and residents of San Francisco who utilize and even pay for our projects through taxpayer dollars.  In my mind, the project comes first, and will be here long after we are.  So when I hear our representatives from our "sponsoring agencies" or "operational departments" say things like "I don't care what my building looks like" or "it's my money" I take note.  The projects we deliver are for the people and need to last generations and therefore be of the highest standard and not value engineered to the point they will fall apart in 10 years.



    ------------------------------
    Julia Laue, AIA, NCARB, LEED AP
    Principal Architect & Bureau Manager
    Bureau of Architecture, SF Public Works
    San Francisco, CA
    ------------------------------



  • 10.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-07-2023 06:05 PM

    WHO: My primary roles are P.I.C. and subject matter expert in Law Enforcement and 9-1-1 Emergency Communications facility design.  The rest of my time has me working on local projects for municipalities, and parks and recreation districts. For 30+ years, my work has been in public sector architecture. I also provide subject matter expertise in physical security.

    WHAT: Public Safety work continues to be in extremely high demand, and I expect that this will continue for the next several years. For law enforcement projects, it is really challenging to keep up with the workload and finding staff who are interested in learning about all of the various specialties involved is very difficult. As I'm getting closer to retirement, I am very concerned about who will take over. My current employer doesn't have a plan in place and that keeps me up at night. Other things that keep me up at night include how do we work with a project team to design resilient and sustainable buildings that will actually work through significant hazardous events (natural disasters, weather events, etc.), out of control construction inflation, supply chain issues, and ever-increasing owner expectations.



    ------------------------------
    Raymond Lee AIA
    FGM Architects
    Chicago IL
    ------------------------------



  • 11.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-08-2023 09:13 PM

    WHO: I am a "Public Architect" in the purest sense from my time in the U.S. Air Force, serving for 20 years and retiring as a Lt. Colonel. For all of that time I did healthcare facility planning, design, and construction and struggled mightily to achieve licensure. In my time since the military I have continued to work on public architecture from the private sector, mainly healthcare facilities for the U.S. military and veterans, ultimately now leading and owning a Service Disabled Veteran Owned Small Business architecture firm named Alesia Architecture in the Omaha, Nebraska metropolitan area.

    WHAT: There is no one thing that keeps me up at night. As a business owner I worry about the long arc of the business as opposed to the day to day. There is always stuff to handle day to day, but securing good strong work for the future, feeding the careers of the 20+ staff I serve, providing our clients the facilities they rightly deserve, staying abreast of technology, and providing for employees an optimal work-life-family balance are the main things I worry about. I sincerely try to not sweat the day to day, the small stuff. It happens to all of us, focusing on the short term, but the long view is the goal.



    ------------------------------
    Richard Onken AIA
    Alesia Architecture
    Elkhorn NE
    ------------------------------



  • 12.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-08-2023 10:14 PM

    Rich,

    Good to hear from you and that you've found footing in the private sector.

    Ed



    ------------------------------
    Edmond Gauvreau, FAIA
    Washington, DC
    ------------------------------



  • 13.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-08-2023 05:40 PM

    WHO: I am the Chief of Architectural Services Division for Sacramento County. ASD is responsible for delivering all of the County's facility needs from new construction and renovations to space planning/allocation and maintenance repairs. We currently have a $1B 5 year CIP identified, not funded.... lots of job security. 

    WHAT: My major challenges include maintaining QA/QC, training, hiring, implementing plans for continued success, knowledge transfer and staff engagement. 



    ------------------------------
    Bryan Low AIA
    Department of General Services/Chief, Architectural Services Division
    Sacramento CA
    ------------------------------



  • 14.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-08-2023 09:12 PM
    Edited by Andrew Thompson AIA 08-08-2023 09:12 PM

    WHO: I am the County Architect for Passaic County New Jersey. I work directly with our County government and I am involved with building infrastructure and historic preservation.

    WHAT: I just completed with the County and our partners an extensive energy retrofit and a large solar project installation at the County's healthcare facility. My biggest concern is that after 20 years what will be next on the list to keep our facilities viable and competent as technology can make buildings more efficient and energy conscious. Our team just completed the second round of historic preservation projects and I hope the restoration and improvements can go for another 50 years.



    ------------------------------
    Andrew Thompson AIA
    Passaic County
    Paterson NJ
    ------------------------------



  • 15.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-10-2023 05:11 PM
    Edited by Julia M. Laue FAIA 08-10-2023 08:17 PM

    WHO:  I am the Principal Architect overseeing 69 architectural staff for the Bureau of Architecture (BOA), San Francisco Public Works.  My immediate supervisor is Ron Alameida, City Architect & Deputy Director for Public Works.  I have been with the city for 10+ years after 28 years in the private sector.  BOA is an extremely unique architectural organization in that we perform in-house design for our city's assets from Fire Stations & Homeless Shelters to Libraries, but also work heavily with private sector architects to deliver our capital projects.  BOA has been in existence since 1907, formulated not long after the 1906 earthquake in SF.  Some believe we were formed out of a call for more QC/QA and oversight of the design and construction of our Civic Buildings mainly because of the state of the relatively "new" city hall at the time of the earthquake, which was built out of corruption, took 27 years to build, was 400% over budget and the walls were full of sand. With regard to our work with the private sector, our Project Management Bureau oversees the biggest projects which are primarily designed by the private sector architects. Over the last 10 years we have delivered over $2.5B in major projects utilizing private sector architects.  

    WHY:  The bigger question is "Why Architects in Government Matter"?  I see this as a 5 Pt. response as to what we bring to the government and profession as a whole:  1.  The City Government & City Architect as a Client:  San Francisco has a $32B Capital Plan and when we build & maintain Civic architecture, it needs to be BUILT TO LAST as some projects are only realized once in a lifetime. 2.  The City Architect is an advocate for Excellence in Civic Architecture: To ensure the highest quality of design and construction.  3.  The City Architect is a catalyst for Public Architecture that benefits the Community:  Our projects are for the people, paid for the people and should serve the people who deserve the best in their projects.  We also build a lot of Community Centers and Homeless shelters.  4.  The City Architect as Teacher, Mentor & Learning Lab: We have a strong internship program and our interns get to work on a variety of building projects AND see them constructed.  5.  The City Architect as a Keeper of Standards of Excellence and a Steward of Archives: We need to set the bar in sustainability (all buildings LEED Gold minimum) & electrification of new buildings and major renovations & QC/QA.  We also have drawings going back 100 years that need to be archived, scanned and preserved for generations to come as well as future renovations.    

    WHAT:  What keeps me up at night?  Keeping up our standards of excellence (QC/QA & Design quality), ensuring our staff have enough work, aka I have 69 "families" to consider, not just employees, hiring the right staff, and succession planning.  When I retire, I would like to leave this place not only better than when I joined, but also Built To Last, like our buildings.



    ------------------------------
    Julia Laue, AIA, NCARB, LEED AP
    Principal Architect & Bureau Manager
    Bureau of Architecture, SF Public Works
    San Francisco, CA
    ------------------------------



  • 16.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-11-2023 11:06 AM

    Who: Architect with the US Courts

    What: Security is always an issue in both new construction and existing facilities. For new, making sure our design teams understand why certain requirements that may seem obscure are necessary, and with existing, making sure we are keeping up with heightened threats. Also keeping me up is working with GSA to secure funding for deferred maintenance projects in our older buildings. Budgets are always a struggle.

    Regards,

    Pamela

    Pamela (Leonard) Patrick, AIA

    District Architect 

    U. S. District Court, Northern District of Mississippi 

    911 Jackson Ave East

    Oxford, Mississippi 38655

    662-202-6867



    ------------------------------
    Pamela Leonard Patrick AIA
    US District Court, Northern District of Mississippi
    Oxford MS
    ------------------------------



  • 17.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-14-2023 06:04 PM

    WHO: Deputy Director of Capital Planning and Policy for Cook County (the county of Chicago). Been here 6 years, in public agencies a total of 11 years, been licensed for 34 years, balance a private firms working almost exclusively for public agency clients (local, state, and Federal). I am the senior architect in the Department, which manages approximately 500 capital projects annually on 100 or so buildings totaling around 19m SF. Two hospitals, six clinics, twelve courthouses, three large office buildings, and the 5m SF Cook County Jail. Most of my work is focused on the public safety portfolio. My Director and I manage Department staff and four consultant teams. I also lead our procurement, the development of our annual Capital Improvement Plan, and I am the SME for the County on ADA matters.

    WHAT: In addition to the (ahem) challenges with procurement (we've been budgeting a year just to get firms hired...), my main challenge is in the public safety portfolio - the wholesale transformation of our Jail and of our courts system, including the juvenile justice system, is a massive, multi-year planning, political, and technical challenge.



    ------------------------------
    Eric Davis AIA
    Cook County Government
    Oak Park IL
    ------------------------------



  • 18.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-16-2023 09:58 AM

    Who: I'm the Executive Director of Facilities, Maintenance and Construction for the Metropolitan Nashville Public Schools, Nashville TN. I have oversight of several departments including Facility Planning and Construction, Facilities and Grounds Maintenance, Custodial Services, and Facility Use. I'm also responsible for leasing of our facilities. We have over 14.3 million square feet in 160 facilities and 2,600 acres of property. We prepare and administer our Capital Improvement budget submitted each year to the mayor's office which reflects a Capital Plan over 6 years.  We coordinate our services with various other Nashville Departments including the Fire Department, Police Department, General Services, Public Works, and Parks and Recreation among others. We currently have over $300,000,000 in design, under construction or planned construction and Deferred Maintenance projects. 

    What: There are many things that keep me up at night. It's almost too hard to quantify or prioritize. I'd say for the most part, are our systems going doing down in a particular school where our students haven't the ability to be in a learning environment conducive to a quality education. Differed maintenance is a big deal here.  Another is weather emergencies such as severe storms we can and often have here, resulting in destruction of our schools such as happened March 20, 2020. That occurrence most definitely kept me up at night. It's often not a matter of "if", but "when". We do our best with differed maintenance projects, but we can't control mother nature.  I think finally getting schools designed and opened in an efficient manner on time and within a well thought out budget. Those are the types of incidences that keep me awake.  



    ------------------------------
    David R Proffitt, AIA
    Nashville TN
    ------------------------------



  • 19.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-17-2023 05:40 PM

    I'm recently retired after serving as Associated Vice Chancellor for Capital Planning at Maricopa Community College District. At the height of college enrollments, a number of years ago, we were one of the largest community college districts in the country, serving nearly 250,000 students each year at 10 campuses and another dozen or so smaller education centers located throughout the greater Phoenix Arizona area. 

    Funding- with a capital F- always was the greatest concern. Capital funding for expansions and remodeling generally could be linked to growth or specific needs. Maintenance funding was an on-going nightmare, trying to keep millions of square feet in operation with only the barest of daily maintenance budgets and next to no preventive/anticipative budgets available.  We finally were able to fund a PM and Facility Condition study to quantify how much, what, and where we needed preventive maintenance work for the next 20 years and convinced our Board to fund bits at a time to chip away at it.  In the meantime, we always had to assure we had enough money to address emergency maintenance as things broke or were damaged.

    Next, what kept me up at night was our Governing Board. We operated in a very politically conservative, generally anti-tax community, including our State government, that continuously reduced funding to higher education.  It was an on-going battle with our Board to get approvals for funding capital and maintenance needs, often debating even minor purchases. I never could understand why someone would seek and serve in a public position at a public institution with a leading goal to starve the institution of the financial resources it needed, when the resources could be obtained for just an additional few dollars per household in additional tax support.

    Someone also mentioned emergencies, like weather damage. We can't control that, but we can plan for it through disaster recovery exercises.  That is critical for everyone in facilities.  Table top an exercise of what will happen if one of your schools or locations is lost to weather or fire.  In advance, plan where operations, employees, students, patients, prisoners.... will move to, emergency procurement processes, vendors that will be needed for emergency support and products. What would happen if you lost an important facility for short term- water line break, mold scare, and yes for all of us, closure for a crime scene in case of a shooting, for example. Where and how do operations continue for the week or so of closure we'll need?  Can people work at home?  Can they be moved to other locations? Do we have partnerships with local schools, churches, community centers, etc. that might provide some temporary space for us? Make those connections and arrangements now.  Work on it all in advance- what would be needed.  Is your IT department up to the task to make alternate network and system access available in an emergency to people working at home or at other locations, whether your own locations or temporary ones. You will sleep better with a little pre-planning.



    ------------------------------
    Arlen Solochek, FAIA
    Owner/Principal/Founder
    Arlen Solochek FAIA, Consulting Architect
    Phoenix, AZ
    ArlenSolochek@gmail.com
    ------------------------------



  • 20.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-18-2023 11:57 AM

    I am so impressed and grateful to everyone who has responded so far - we have so much in common, especially with respect to the need for funding - for good planning - to address long-standing capital maintenance and repair.  PA knowledge community staff and I will assemble a document from this discussion that we can use for planning events for next year that meet your needs - and give a platform for your voices.  

    Please keep posting your answers and thank you!  



    ------------------------------
    Ludmilla Pavlova-Gillham AIA
    University of Massachusetts
    Amherst MA
    ------------------------------



  • 21.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-21-2023 07:20 PM

    I am now a "former" public architect (City Architect, City of San Antonio), as I retired two years ago.  It is funny, I still talk about "we" when referring to the City, as I still feel that sense of "ownership" and responsibility. I continue to press for better project planning, more and better communication, collaboration, and team building within capital projects through my nonprofit, the Institute for Leadership in Capital Projects (I-LinCP). I also continue to facilitate Project Partnering and Owners Project Requirements (OPR) workshops, which I have been doing since 2005 and even (Lightly) while I was with the City. So, I am not "retired"!

     

    The first thing that is usually mentioned when I facilitate partnering workshops and ask the question, "What contributes the most to a positive project outcome?" is "open and honest communication." When that happens, trust is enabled, which is the foundation for a positive and effective team.

    I believe the public architect and project Owner representatives have a tremendous responsibility to effectively lead the project team. This I call being a strong Owner and an attractive client.

     

    What used to keep me up at night are the politics that were played at the City and the second-guessing by "leadership" who thought they knew better than the project teams. I do not miss that at all, but I do miss the architects and other project managers and staff who I used to lead, as well as having a positive influence on our projects.

     

    Carol M. Warkoczewski, MSOLE, AIA

    Collaborator, Facilitator, Speaker, Visionary

    Retired, City Architect, City of San Antonio

    Founder & CVO, Institute for Leadership in Capital Projects (I-LinCP.org)

    Principal, Synergy Builders Consulting, LLC (SynergyBuilders.com)

    cwarkoczewski@gmail.com

    M: 512-914-1201

     






  • 22.  RE: WHO are you as a public architect and WHAT is keeping you up at night?

    Posted 08-21-2023 08:53 PM

    WHO:  I am the 1994 chair of the Committee on Public Architecture.  I had the priviledge of serving under the first female president of the AIA – Susan Maxman.  When I joined the commttee in 1989, worked for the City of Dallas helping to complete their capital improvement program.  By the time I became the chair I was the University of Arkansas campus architect.  We were working on the largest capital improvement program in the university's history called the College Bond Program created by a former governor named Bill Clinton.  I also worked for Bass Pro Shops as they expanded their fleet of stores.  All together I was an owner's architect for about 17 years.  

     

    I have always thought that the owners' architects have the biggest influence on the built environment.  In addition, Public Architects and Corporate Architects are essentially the only clients in the Institute.  We can provide input and guidance that no other group in the AIA can give.  

     

    Although I have returend to the traditional side of the practice, I use what I learned frequently to improve our practice. Because I have that experience, I can shape our performance to better meet the needs our our clients' architects. 

     

    WHAT:  My biggest concerns were quality and price.  In terms of quality, I was concerned with the design and the contract documents.  We need designs that are functional, aestetic, and in context with their site and surrounding.  Con the construction side, we need buildings that are built to meet the contract requirements.  Included in that are the craftsmanship, appearance and durability of the work.  Price is important as well.  On the one hand, I was fighting to get a fair fee for our consultants.  On the other hand, I had to control the escalating costs of construction.  I was equally concerned with getting a fair price for our contractors additional work.