Ms. Leavitt:
You assume group members share your predicate conclusion - that there IS in fact a demonstrable disconnect
[between Architects and Preservationists]. However, you do not set forth the underlying reasoning, or proof (or reference to proof) for that proposition. I do not see how one can provide a meaningful response with input that would be 'usable' by you as part of an objective analysis (and somehow folded into a thesis dissertation) unless you first explain how you arrived at the conclusion(s) you wish others to accept. You say input you receive will not be incorporated into the thesis. Generally a thesis is fact-based and would footnote and include the input/information upon which the author relies - so that it does not simply become an undocumented/unsupported opinion letter.
As a start, with respect to your initial assumption, I would question whether (in practice) what percentage/proportion of preservationists are architects, or trained in architecture - and are thus living a double life (and so could not be any more intimately connected to both disciplines). One of the attributes of well-educated and broadly experienced architects (little A) is a deep appreciation of historic design and construction - both aesthetic and substantive aspects- and the inherent value of preservation. With that in mind, I have some reticence in buying into the position you take in advance of accumulating the broad input you now seek.
Your proposition may be entirely supportable, but without providing others the basis for it, you leave readers floating in the ether. Is the proposition simply your personal impression - or something you have arrived at after research, study and debate with others more experienced in both fields?
Respectfully,
Howard
------------------------------
Howard I. Littman, AIA, Emeritus
Forensic Architect, Expert Witness
Agoura Hills, CA
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 01-19-2020 16:10
From: Skyla Leavitt
Subject: Architects vs. Preservationists: Is there a disconnect between the fields? (Seeking responses now!)
Note: This is a time sensitive post seeking responses now through April 2020.
Hi all!
I am currently developing my terminal project paper (similar to a thesis) for my M.S. in Historic Preservation degree. I have a background in architecture, and since I have taken preservation classes as a student of both fields, I have noticed something: there appears to be a disconnect between architects and preservationists in practice and in perception. For my paper, I am exploring the roots of this disconnect and how to combat it.
Below are some prompts to help you respond, but this is not a formal survey and I will not be including any of your personal data in my final submission. Instead, I hope to garner a consensus from practicing professionals and students alike that will either affirm or contradict my initial perception. I have avoided defining my interpretation of this disconnect so as not to influence anyone's response.
- What is your position/profession/background? (for POV context)
- Do you think there is a disconnect between architects and preservationists that impacts the efficacy and success of their interdisciplinary interactions in practice?
- What do you think are the causes of this disconnect?
- Do you think that architects and preservationists hold stereotypical assumptions about the other field that subsequently impacts their interdisciplinary communications and negotiations in practice?
- Can you summarize these assumptions as you believe they are held?
- What do you think can be done to attain more productive interdisciplinary communication between architects and preservationists as it relates to the practice of preservation?
I encourage you to share your thoughts and experiences here. Whether you have been on a project team, acted as a consultant, or are currently a student, I am interested in your opinions. Thank you so much for taking the time to read and respond to this post! (It would be great if you could share it with others as well!) I hope to produce a paper that young practitioners of both fields will find useful, but I can't do that without well-rounded input. I really appreciate any and all contributions! Thank you!
Best,
Skyla
------------------------------
Skyla Kapri Leavitt
University of Oregon | College of Design
Master of Architecture | 2020
M.S. in Historic Preservation | 2020
------------------------------